Amazing Spider-Man #4 Value: Sandman Arrives

Amazing Spider-Man #4 carries the first Sandman, and also the first Betty Brant, which people forget until they are selling. Amazing Spider-Man #4 value starts there.

It is a common book by Silver Age key standards, and that is the most useful thing to know about it.

Why condition does all the work on this one

Some keys are scarce and some are merely valuable. This is the second kind. Copies come up constantly, and the ladder below shows a lot of them, which means a buyer never has to reach for a rough copy.

The practical effect: the spread between a beaten copy and a clean one is proportionally wider here than on a scarce book, because there is always another copy a grade up. A book with 241 documented sales does not reward patience the way a book with twenty does.

The identification job is standard for a 1963 Marvel: 12 cents, a September 1963 indicia date, no bar code, and every reprint naming itself in the small print.

A record with very little underneath it

Two grades on this book have been sold three times each recently, and they are telling the same story.

The 9.2 line reads $32,400 in July 2023, $36,000 in July 2024, then $20,400 in April 2025. Up, then down by almost half in nine months, all at Heritage. The 9.4 line does it too: $50,400 in June 2022 down to $28,800 in April 2025.

April 2025 shows up twice in that paragraph, which is not a coincidence. When several grades of one book all print their weakest recent result in the same sale, the honest reading is that the sale was soft, not that the comic reset. A quote built off that month alone would be too low, and one built off July 2024 alone would be too high.

The $174,000 at 9.6 is from September 2021, the top of the last cycle, and nothing has come close since. It is four and a half years old at this point. I list it because it happened, not because it describes what a 9.6 would bring now, and I would not let a seller anchor to it.

The 9.0 pair shows how far the drop goes: $21,600 in June 2022, $9,219 in April 2025. Same grade, same book, less than half. Everything about this issue argues for reading the dates before the numbers.

As with everything on this site, those figures come through CGC’s reporting of other companies’ auctions and Heritage’s own published results. GoCollect and PriceCharting track Amazing Spider-Man #4 independently, and if their numbers disagree with mine it is worth finding out which of us is wrong.

Amazing Spider-Man #4 value, lane by lane

241 sales tracked back to 2002; here are the three freshest in every grade.

Every row above is a documented sale, verifiable in Heritage’s public Amazing Spider-Man issue index and in CGC’s published auction reporting. 241 results sit behind this book, and on a common key only the recent ones matter.

19 of these share one grade. The CGC 4.0 line reads $1,359 in 2025, $1,800 in 2025, $1,599 in 2026, $1,499 in 2026. $1,359 to $1,499, with the 2026 peak at $2,565.

The grade lanes above are the slabbed market, and most copies of this issue are not slabbed. Raw, ungraded copies sold 31 times on eBay in 2026, from $202 to $4,000, with half of them between $520 and $999. That spread is wider than it looks because raw listings hide the damage a grade would state, so the low end is usually a copy with a problem the photographs did not show and the high end is usually somebody betting on a 6.0 or better.

What a read copy is worth right now

Eighty-four readable copies have sold in the past eighteen months, and the most recent are unusually instructive because three of them share a grade.

Three CGC 3.5 copies sold within eight days of each other in July 2026, at $900, $1,364 and $1,475. Same grade, same week, and the top result is over sixty percent above the bottom one. That is one grade, three sellers, three different sets of photographs and descriptions, and it is the clearest evidence I can give you that how a comic is presented moves the price as much as the label does.

Around them, a 4.0 brought $1,499 and a 4.5 brought $1,500, both on eBay, and a 5.0 brought $1,525 at Heritage in July. Notice that those three are within twenty-six dollars of each other across a grade and a half. The mid-grade market on this book is nearly flat between 3.5 and 5.0.

A 7.0 at $3,172 in July 2026 is where it starts to climb again. If your copy is genuinely clean, that is the row worth aiming at, and it is worth having the grade assessed properly first.

Selling an Amazing Spider-Man #4

1. Grade honestly before you price it. On a common key, condition is nearly the whole number.
2. Twelve cents, September 1963. Reprints and facsimiles say so inside.
3. Sell it with the run if you can. Issues 1 through 10 move better as a block than as singles.
4. Do not press or clean it. Intervention costs more than the wear it hides.

Send photographs and I will place your copy in its grade lane against the same recent sales you can read above. Where you take it next is your call, and the options for selling in Southern California are worth knowing either way.

Related

• Amazing Spider-Man #1.
• The 100 most valuable Silver Age comics.
• What a free appraisal covers.

Cover images on this page are shown small, for identification, with the publisher credited in the caption. If you are a rights holder and want an image removed, contact me and it comes down.